I avoided answering this question but i will now at this point.
The answer is body, even here in the photos section i check out the body,,, if you have a nice body that is what will draw me to your pic... my eye at some point will look at your penis ..
Thats not to say i needs to have a nice body.. because personality and then face (smile, eyes, nose ) are the most important thing to me.
if i see a guy who has a hot body and he has a crap personality then the thought that is in my head is .. "what a waste "
Did you guys notice that not once have i said anything about penis and how it effects my opinion of the guy or my attraction.. because not a hell of lot of thought goes into it... sure some penises appeal to the sense nothing wrong with a pretty penis,but there is no size to what makes a pretty penis, and there is more then one kind of pretty penis... just as there are all kinds of different types of pretty pussy.